Published November 17, 2026 · Last updated November 17, 2026 · 9-minute read
TL;DR
- Friendship takes time: about 50 hours together for a casual friend, 90 for a friend, 200+ for a close one (University of Kansas).
- A one-off party gives you minutes with people you won’t see again. A group that meets every week or month lets the hours add up.
- NYC has dozens of these groups on Luma: reading parties, dinner clubs, game nights, walking groups. Most are free to RSVP.
- Most NYC Luma events aren’t featured on Luma’s discover page.
- First month: pick two groups, go to each three times, invite one person to coffee.
To make friends in NYC, join two or three groups that meet on a schedule (a reading party, a dinner club, a game night) and keep going back. Friendship forms through repeated hours with the same people, roughly 50 hours for a casual friend. One-off mixers rarely get you there. A weekly or monthly group does.
Everyone who moves to New York hears the same thing: it’s the loneliest crowded city in the world. I don’t think that’s quite right. The people who end up with a real circle here usually didn’t find a better party. They found a smaller room, and they went back to it.
Why is it so hard to make friends in NYC?
It’s hard to make friends in NYC because newcomers get lots of first meetings and very few second ones. The city is full of events. What it’s short on, for a new arrival, is repetition. You meet someone great at a rooftop thing in Williamsburg, you swap Instagram handles, and then you both go back to your separate twelve-hour days.
The national numbers make this worse. When the US Surgeon General declared loneliness a public health epidemic in 2023, his report found that about half of U.S. adults say they’ve experienced loneliness, and that Americans spent about 20 minutes a day in person with friends in 2020, down from 60 minutes nearly two decades earlier. People aged 15 to 24 reported a 70 percent drop. His advice for individuals was refreshingly low-tech: join community groups. So the person next to you at the party is probably as starved for a repeat plan as you are. They just won’t be the one to suggest it.
New York adds its own friction. People move in and out constantly, commutes eat the evenings, and everyone’s calendar is full of work things that look social but aren’t. If you’ve ever had a “let’s definitely get dinner” text sit unanswered for three weeks, you know the shape of it.
How many hours does it take to make a friend?
It takes about 50 hours together to turn an acquaintance into a casual friend, about 90 hours to become friends, and more than 200 hours to become close friends. Those numbers come from Jeffrey Hall’s 2018 study at the University of Kansas, which surveyed 355 adults who had moved in the previous six months and were looking for new friends, then checked the result with 112 first-year students.
One detail from the study matters a lot in New York: the hours have to be social. Hanging out, joking around and playing games counted; hours spent working together counted for much less. That’s bad news for anyone hoping their office will double as a social life, and this city’s long workdays make that hope common. A colleague you see fifty hours a month can stay an acquaintance for years.
“It takes roughly 50 hours of time together to move from mere acquaintance to casual friend.” — University of Kansas, on Jeffrey Hall’s 2018 study
Run the arithmetic on a typical NYC social life. A two-hour mixer where you meet ten new people gives each of them a few minutes of you. Even if you spend half an hour with the one person you clicked with, that’s 1% of the way to a casual friendship, and you probably won’t see them again. Now take a reading party that meets every other week. Two hours a session with roughly the same regulars gets you to 50 hours in about a year, and much faster if a coffee or a walk gets added on the side. That’s the whole case for recurring groups, and it’s why I’d skip the big mixers entirely in your first month.
Which NYC groups actually meet again and again?
The NYC groups that build friendships are the ones with a fixed format and future dates on the calendar: reading parties, dinner clubs, game nights and walking groups. Discussion clubs and community centres belong on the list too. When I went through New York’s upcoming Luma events in November 2026, these formats showed up again and again, hosted by organizers who post a new date every week or month.
| Format | What happens | Examples on Luma (November 2026) | Good for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Reading parties | Bring a book, read together for a while, then talk | Reading Rhythms NYC (sessions from Staten Island to Bushwick), Open Book Club, Lit Club NYC book swaps | Introverts; people who don’t drink |
| Dinner clubs | Dinner with a small table of strangers, often themed | The Dinner Table Club, Rusty Supper Club x Pleased to Meet You | Fast conversation; food people |
| Game nights | Tabletop and role-playing games with mixed groups | Counterspell Games pop-ups, SideQuest IRL (now on its 50th edition) | Anyone who’d rather play than mingle |
| Discussion clubs | A question or text, then a structured conversation | The New York Philosophy Club, UNMUTED debates | People who like arguing (nicely) |
| Walks and runs | A route, a pace, a coffee after | City Girls Who Walk, Welcome to Chinatown Runs | Mornings; low pressure |
| Phone-free nights | Concerts or gatherings with phones put away | Kanso: Phone-Free Experiences | Actually being present |
| Community centres | Open gym, talks, support groups | Brooklyn Community Pride Center | Neighbourhood roots |
Look at the second column before the third. A dinner club gives you two hours at a small table instead of two minutes in a crowd, and if you go back each month, the regulars stop being strangers. A reading party gives you a built-in opener (“what are you reading?”) that works even if small talk exhausts you. I’d trust any group that has posted its next three dates more than one with a beautiful Instagram and a single event.
Key takeaways: - Friendship is built from repeated social hours, not from meeting more people. - Pick formats that seat you with the same small group: dinners, reading parties, game nights. - Judge a group by its calendar. Future dates mean it’s alive. - Give any group three visits before you decide.
Do friend-making apps work in New York?
Apps work for the first meeting and struggle with the second, which is the one that matters. On r/AskNYC, someone recently asked whether anyone had actually found a book club through an app. The top reply called the apps “a crapshoot, mostly full of dead groups” (thread). The people who did find a lasting group got there through an indie bookstore’s bulletin board, a neighbourhood Facebook group or a post on r/nycmeetups, and one Astoria book club has been running for about ten years. That matches what I see in event listings: a group with no upcoming date is usually a group that has stopped meeting.
Matching services that put you at dinner with strangers have a real use. They get you out of the apartment, and some people meet a friend on the first try. The problem is structural, not personal. A new table every week resets your hours to zero, and Hall’s numbers say that’s the one thing you can’t afford. Use an app to find a starting point, then move to something with regulars.
Where are NYC’s social events actually listed?
Most of New York’s public social events are listed on Luma, but most of them never appear on Luma’s discover page. Hidden Events tracks 144 upcoming public Luma events in New York right now, and 62.2% of them aren’t featured on discover. Luma’s discover page favours a short list of big events. The reading party in Prospect Heights and the small dinner club in Flatiron usually aren’t on it.
That’s why so many people in NYC subreddits end up stitching together newsletters, Partiful links from friends and venue pages. Partiful events are mostly private invitations, so they help once you have friends and not before. Eventbrite is better for ticketed shows than for small recurring groups. Our explainer on why Luma hides events covers how discover picks what to show, and how to find hidden events covers the general method.
The quickest route is the full New York events page, which lists everything we find, featured or not. For the next few days, use things happening in NYC this weekend. Smaller, topic-led gatherings are under NYC meetups.
What should your first month in NYC look like?
In your first month, pick two recurring groups, go to each one three times, and say yes to one small plan with someone you met there. That’s six events and one coffee. It sounds modest, and it works better than twenty one-off parties.
| Week | Do |
|---|---|
| 1 | Open the NYC events page, shortlist five recurring groups near where you live or work, RSVP to two |
| 2 | Go to both. Learn three names. Ask what they’re going to next |
| 3 | Go back to both. Same seats if you can, same people if you can |
| 4 | Third visit. Invite one person to coffee before the next session, or to another event on the list |
Timing helps. Across all of New York’s Luma events, Wednesday is the busiest day and 70.3% of events start in the evening, so midweek evenings are where your options are.
The moment a group turns into friends is usually small: a regular texts to ask whether you’re coming next week. Nobody sends that text to someone they’ve met once. It arrives after the second or third time you’ve been there, which is why the plan counts visits instead of events.
How do you turn someone you met at an event into a friend?
You turn an event acquaintance into a friend by inviting them to a second, smaller thing within a week. Hall’s own advice is blunt: “You can’t make people spend time with you, but you can invite them.” Most people are waiting to be asked, and most people never ask.
Make the invite specific and low-stakes. “Want to grab coffee before the next reading party?” is easy to say yes to. “We should hang out sometime” is easy to forget. If you hate initiating, attach your invite to the group: suggest dinner after the session, or ask two regulars to go to another event together. Our piece on what to say at a meetup when you hate networking has openers and exit lines that work just as well at a book club as at a tech night.
Then keep showing up. The hours do the rest, and they only add up if the same people keep seeing each other. If you’re on the professional side of the city too, NYC networking events work the same way: the third visit is the one that counts.
About the author: Himanshu Saleria, founder of Hidden Events. I love meeting people. I’ve been attending events, hosting them, and picking up patterns along the way for what makes a gathering worth showing up to. Hidden Events surfaces what I’ve been finding. LinkedIn
How we research: event counts come from Hidden Events’ own crawl of public Luma events in New York, refreshed every 4 hours. Group examples are organizers with upcoming public Luma events in November 2026. Other figures link to their original source: University of Kansas on Jeffrey Hall’s friendship study, AP via PBS NewsHour on the US Surgeon General’s loneliness advisory, r/AskNYC thread on finding a book club through apps.